Best Breast Pumps

Are you looking for the best breast pumps? You are on the right path. Pumping has a learning curve but buying the wrong breast pump for you or a low performance one may turn you off from using one at all. Breast pumps have come a long way and technology has helped them to become a must have in your nursery list.

We all agree that breast milk provides your baby with the best possible start in life. It is proven to improve baby’s health and nutrition. For many mothers, exclusively breastfeeding their babies for the recommended time by the World Health Organization (WHO) is not an option. Breastfeeding is a natural process but it is not always easy for parents.

Breast pumps give mothers the opportunity to provide breast milk to their babies for as long as they have a supply even when they are not around. It also helps mothers to have a good night sleep and the wearable pumps give them back their confidence and freedom to pump on the go. While some wearable pumps do not require a special bra to be used, others hands free and conventional breast pumps do, so make sure you also buy a good pumping bra or expression bustier.

My Top 3 Picks

Best Electric Breast Pump

Medela Pump In Style MaxFlow

Price: $375.00

Medela Pump In Style MaxFlow

  • Oval breast shields for a better fit
  • 2-Phase Expression® technology that mimics baby’s natural sucking rhythm
  • 10 Hospital grade levels of suction
  • Bottle Capacity: 5 oz/150 mL per side
  • Closed system, BPA free
  • Designed to pump several times a day
  • Battery pack for convenient pumping away from the power outlet

Best Wearable Smart Breast Pump

Elvie Double Electric Breast Pumps

Price: $549.99

Elvie Double Electric Breast Pumps

  • Robust and intuitive app
  • Pump fit inside your bra
  • 9 levels – Hospital grade suction
  • Containers Capacity 5 oz/150 ml per side
  • Closed system, BPA free
  • Full battery charge lasts 2.5 hours of pumping
  • HSA/FSA Funds accepted

Best Manual Breast Pump

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

Price: $34.00

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

  • Lightweight breast pump
  • Reusable bottle holds up to 5.4 oz/160 ml
  • Ergonomic, easy-express handle to reduce hand fatigue
  • Dual mode pumping and Natural Wave nipple
  • Pump directly into storage bags or bottles for a convenient and hygienic pumping

Which are the Best Breast Pumps in 2022?

  1. Medela In Style MaxFlow Electric Double Breastpump
  2. Elvie Double Electric Breast Pump
  3. Spectra S1 Plus Double Electric Breast Pump
  4. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
  5. Medela Swing Single Electric Breast Pump
  6. Philips AVENT Double Electric Breast Pump
  7. Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 Double Electric Breast Pump

1. Medela In Style MaxFlow Electric Double Breastpump

Medela In Style MaxFlow Electric Double Breastpump
Price: $375.00

The Medela In Style is one of the best breast pumps in the market and it is worth every penny. Moms love the versatility of this double electric pump. The Medela pump comes with a battery pack for convenient pumping when you are away from a power outlet and the double pump system allows you to pump only one breast or both, easily adapting to your needs.

It is a hospital grade breast pump designed to mimic a baby’s natural sucking pattern. The suction is more vibrational and less of a hard pole like other previous medela pumps. Customers claim that it is very easy to clean, the parts dry quickly, and it has great suction. It is also very quiet which allows you to use it at night or while breastfeeding your baby.

The flanges are substantially more comfortable than other flanges. However, flanges are in the shorter side of the spectrum so if you have long or elastic nipples they might touch the membrane. Using the correct flange sizing and lowering the suction usually helps.

Features

  • 10 Hospital grade levels of suction
  • Bottle Capacity: 5 oz/150 mL per side
  • 2 sizes of PersonalFit Flex™ breast shields with soft rim and oval shape for better comfort and fit
  • Advanced motor generates vacuum with MaxFlow™ micro-vibrations for effective milk expression
  • Clinically proven to increase milk volume by 11.8%
  • Easy to Use: Few parts to clean and assemble
  • Closed system which prevents milk from entering the tubing
  • 2-Phase Expression® technology that mimics baby’s natural sucking rhythm
  • Designed for moms who pump several times a day
  • All parts that touch the milk are BPA free
  • Very portable. It comes with everything you need to pump at home or away, including cooler bag and stylish carry bag
  • Includes a battery pack for convenient pumping away from the power outlet (batteries not included)

Considerations

Consider buying the pumping bra to avoid having to hold the pump to your breasts with your hands. This will not only make it less tiring for you, it will also allow you to be more mobile while pumping by freeing your hands.

If your budget allows it, it is very handy to purchase extra nipple collars, bottles, flanges and membranes so you get a break on handwashing all components every time you pump.

If you feel that the membranes are starting to lose suction do not hurry to buy new ones. First make sure they are positioned properly and try to moisten them with breast milk or purified water, this can help create a better seal.

2. Elvie Double Electric Breast Pumps

Elvie Double Electric Breast Pumps
Price: $549.99

The Elvie wearable breast pump is a state-of-the-art smart pump. It has the most robust and intuitive app to control the pump from your phone. You can monitor in real-time the milk volume and personalize the pump intensity settings to match your personal preference.

This wearable breast pump also wins the gold medal for quietest pump, even on its higher setting. Being so quiet and able to sit entirely inside your bra, gives you confidence to pump anywhere. Some reviews claim to successfully go shopping while pumping. All these and more gave the Elvie breast pump a well deserved first spot on the 7 best wearable breast pump list.

Other Features

  • Hands free pump without wires
  • Option to personalize the breast pump to your preference: 2 modes and 14 intensity settings
  • Option to change brightness on your pump
  • Reusable bottle holds up to 5 oz/150 ml, fridge and freezer safe
  • Single or double pumping by assigning each pump a side to be tracked in the app
  • Insights feature of the app to learn more about your pumping behavior
  • 2h charging time via micro-USB, for 2.5 hours of pumping (depending on your settings)
  • Includes Breast Shields in two sizes. A third size (21 mm) can be purchased separately
  • Closed system, Dishwasher safe, and BPA free
  • 2 year warranty on the Hub (pump mechanism) and 90 day warranty on washable components
  • HSA/FSA Funds accepted

Considerations

If you are a newbie to breast pumps in general, be patient and don’t give up right away. It is normal to have some spilling and overflowing when getting used to a breast pump, and the Elvie wearable breast pump isn’t an exception. Try not to bend over too far while pumping because the breast-milk will get on the sensor and the reading will be inaccurate, resulting in the breast pump turning off automatically. It will interpret that the collection bottle is full or close to.

Keep in mind that the Elvie is a pump-and-pour model so there are no bags for storage. Also, this pump begins with a stimulation mode, and it won’t move into expressing mode until it detects that your let-down has started. Consider wearing a well fitted bra to improve the pump performance overall.

3. Spectra S1 Plus Double Electric Breast Pump

Spectra S1 Plus Double Electric Breast Pump
Price: $200.00

The Spectra S1 Plus is a very powerful breast pump that will make your breastfeeding journey more comfortable. It is a versatile pump with single and double pumping capabilities. The built-in rechargeable battery is a very nice feature, allowing you to pump and move around your home or office freely, without having to unplug or detach.

The battery is excellent and I can go several days between charges. I don’t notice any difference in performance between when it runs on battery and when it’s plugged in. Compared to other electric breast pumps, the Spectra has way less parts to clean.

Being so quiet and the soft night-light make this portable breast pump a great option for late night pumping sessions. This breast pump also shuts off automatically after 30 mins but it has a timer that helps moms to stay on track with the recommended 10-15 minute sessions.

Other Features

  • Single or Double Pump capability
  • 12 vacuum suction in expression mode
  • 2-phase expression technology
  • 5 massage mode settings
  • Reusable bottle holds up to 5.4 oz/160 ml
  • Built in night-light and LCD screen with one-touch operation
  • Two years warranty on pump & 90 days on accessories
  • Electronic memory control with 30min auto power shut-off
  • Closed system ensures hygiene and motor performance
  • Built-in rechargeable battery to pump on-the-go
  • All parts that come into contact with breastmilk are made with BPA free materials

Considerations

If you are a first time mom or have no experience pumping before, make sure you size your nipples correctly in order to buy the correct flange size. Aslo, keep in mind that two breasts do not look exactly the same so do not be alarmed if you need different flange size for each of them.

Consider buying an extra set of flanges, duckbill valves and bottles if you’re planning to pump often throughout the day, to allow one set to dry before you need to use it again. Also, parts are not as readily available as other brands so consider buying other bottles that will work fine with this pump like Philip Avent and MAM Bottles.

4. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
Price: $34.99

The Lansinoh is a great manual breast pump that is also budget-friendly. It has no squeaky handles or leaky shields, and the suction is fantastic for such a little pump. Moms like it as an additional pump to have around for occasional use.

Like all manual pumps they lack efficiency when compared with electrical pumps and pumping sessions require more effort. But, the Lansinoh has two pumping modes that allows you to pump faster, and the handle was specially designed so you can pump for a longer period of time before your hand gets tired. It is also lightweight, has few parts to clean and it pumps directly into the feeding bottle which make it easy to carry in your bag for quiet pumping sessions.

Other Features

  • Lightweight breast pump with an ergonomic, easy-express handle to reduce hand fatigue
  • Dual mode pumping and Natural Wave nipple.
  • Pump directly into breastmilk storage bags or bottles for a convenient, hygienic pumping that saves precious milk and time
  • Reusable bottle holds up to 5.4 oz/160 ml

Considerations

Keep in mind that like all manual pups you will have to focus on holding it in the right position to create a good seal. Also, play around until you find the right pump intensity and rhythm. If you are a first time mom or new to manual breast pumps, you may find this is a bit tricky to do. If you are having troubles or taking too long before let-down occurs, try gently massaging your breast.

Bottom line, the Lansinoh is a great manual pump, better than hand expressing but not as efficient as using a good electric breast pump.

5. Medela Swing Single Electric Breast Pump

Medela Swing Single Electric Breast Pump
Price: $169.99

The Medela Swing is the perfect breast pump for moms who only pump occasionally or when nursing. This is the smallest and lightest single electric breast pump on the market. It is very handy for traveling or going out, it fits inside your purse, backpack or diaper bag.

Even though the Medela Swing was designed for occasional use, many moms claim that they use it on a regular basis successfully. It also offers a battery operated option that works just as well as being plugged in, making it ideal for multitaskers and working moms. This is one of those products that seem simple but end up loved by customers.

Features

  • Reusable bottle holds up to 5 oz/150 ml
  • All parts that touch breastmilk are made without BPA, DEHP and other phthalates
  • 2-Phase Expression® technology
  • Compact and lightweight motor that fits easily into your purse, backpack, or tote bag
  • Two Power Supply Options: AC power adapter and batteries (4 AA batteries not included)
  • Comes with Medela’s Calma® nipple, scientifically proven to make switching a breeze

Considerations

Some reviewers claimed having problems with the flange and others don’t but this should not turn you off from buying the Medela Swing, if you believe this is the right pump for you. Medela includes an extra two or three flanges with the purchase of the pump, so it is an easy fix if something were to happen.

Also be aware that you might see some condensation build up in the tubing during a pumping session but if you run the pump, detached from the bottle, for a few minutes after you’re done pumping, the condensation clears out.

Note that the US version of this pump does not include the Calma® nipple set.

6. Philips AVENT Double Electric Breast Pump

Philips AVENT Double Electric Breast Pump
Price: $270.00

The Philips AVENT is great to pump on the go. It is small and comes with a belt to hold the pump while pumping, which together with the rechargeable batteries allows you to move around easily and pump wherever life takes you.

I love that the pump comes with a large bag to carry everything and it’s big enough to fit various personal items as well as pump parts. So you could turn this bag into a diaper bag when you need it. It is one of the most convenient breast pumps in this list due to the fact that you can easily find extra bottles and other parts in most stores.

Features

  • Reusable bottle holds up to 4 oz/125 ml (other bottle size available)
  • Natural motion technology combines suction and nipple stimulation for quick milk flow
  • Soft and adaptive silicone cushion, fits nipple sizes of up to 30mm/1.18 inches
  • Includes pumping belt, bag and pouch
  • Rechargeable battery to give you freedom to move around
  • Personalize with 8 stimulation and 16 expression levels
  • Closed system for hygienic expression, no milk in the tubing
  • Bottle and Teat are BPA free. All breast pump parts that get in contact with milk are also BPA-free

Considerations

Keep in mind that this is a double pump and a full battery charge will usually allow for 30 min of pumping. So depending on how long your pumping sessions are, consider charging the pump after each session to prevent it from cutting your session short.

This is the best breast pump for over producer moms who need a quick session to empty while on the go. But if you have a low milk supply, then it may be best to buy a stronger pump as a main one to keep your supply up.

7. Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 Double Electric Breast Pump

Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 Double Electric Breast Pump
Price: $160.00

The Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 double breast pump is very versatile, allowing you to use it as a hands free or standard pump. This small and lightweight breast pump can be used with batteries allowing you to take it mostly everywhere or plugged into the wall. Thanks to the long cord that comes with this double electric pump, you would still be able to do other things while pumping.

Everyone seems to love this wearable pump. The pump suction is really good and having five ComfortFit® flange sizes to choose from makes it easier to find the right one for your breast. Also, this smart breast pump is compatible with inexpensive brand bottles.

Features

  • Highly Customizable pump settings and built-in memory to remember them
  • 8 hospital strength suction levels and 3 different pumping styles to mimic your baby’s natural feeding pattern
  • 2 mode technology for let down and expression modes to maximize milk expression
  • Kit includes 2 Standard (25mm) and 2 Large (30.5mm) ComfortFit® flanges
  • 5 ComfortFit® flange sizes available (21mm, 25mm, 28mm, 30.5mm and 36mm)
  • Ultra Quiet hospital grade pump
  • Comfortable rims: ComfortFit flanges are soft against sensitive skin while forming a tight seal

Considerations

Consider using the flange sizer on Lansinoh website to make sure you are using the correct flange size. It is very important you use the correct size for best pump performance.

The membranes are super important to maintain suction and not have milk backing up into places it shouldn’t be but they are delicate so it is good to have some extra ones with you at home for emergencies.

If you like to use the pump without being plugged into the wall to be more mobile, consider getting a charger and rechargeable batteries (6 x AA). Also, it is a good idea to invest in the car plug available at Lansinoh. These things will allow you to take the pump with you and use it anywhere anytime.

Types of Breast Pumps

Many will say that there are three main types of breast pump in the market: manual, electric and battery powered but I’d like to add one more, smart breast pumps.

We are living in an era of technology and innovation where “smart” products are becoming a staple in our daily life. Smart connected products can offer superior customization, performance, and customers value them relative more over the traditional products.

  • Manual Breast Pumps: They are hand-operated, quiet, lightweight, portable, inexpensive, and designed to be used at one breast at a time. Manual pumps work by placing the pump over your breast with one hand, while the other hand will pump the handle to create suction. They are recommended for occasional pumping only because, to make it work, you’ll have to keep pumping the handle to maintain suction. This can be a lot of work when done multiple times throughout the day.
  • Electric Breast Pumps: These pumps required electricity to run the motor and create the suction. They need to be plugged into an electrical outlet which limits the user’s mobility while pumping but they usually are the most powerful type of breast pump in the market. You can find them as single or double electric breast pumps depending on their ability to pump one or both breasts at the same time respectively.
  • Battery Operated Breast Pumps: They are also called hands free, wearable or wireless breast pumps. These pumps are also electric pumps but they get their electrical power from batteries to run the motor and create the suction. This future makes them more mobile giving moms the freedom to multitask or to pump on the go. Their suction level can be lower in some models but high-end brands can easily compete with standard electric pumps. A good battery operated breast pump should offer you hospital grade suction and not require a mom to hold the pump with one hand while pumping. The main purpose of the battery powered pump is to be truly hands-free.
  • Smart Breast Pumps: Smart pumps are cutting edge technology in the breast pump world. They connect directly to intuitive apps allowing you to control the pump from your phone. The pump intensity settings can be personalized to match your personal preference. High-end models offer support, tracking of pumping sessions, lactation advice, and send reminder messages to keep you on track through their apps as well.

Which Type is the Best Breast Pump for you?

When trying to figure out which type of breast pump is ideal for you, take into account your needs and lifestyle. The best breast pump for many mothers is not necessarily the right fit for you and your baby.

Choosing a suitable breast pump depends on many factors:

  • Personal lifestyle: Are you a working mom? Do you have other childrens? Are you a multitasker? Do you go out or on trips often? These are questions you need to ask yourself before making a decision about which type of pump is right for you. If you answer yes to any of these questions you probably need an electric portable breast pump. Also known as a wearable/ hands free pump, they give you the freedom to pump on the go and multitask while pumping at home or work. These pumps are battery operated.
  • Pumping Location: Think about where you are planning to be pumping: home, work, car, outside, etc. Some pumps are more efficient than others in different settings. If you are planning to pump regularly at home an electric pump with hospital grade suction is the best breast pump for you. On the other hand, if you like to multitask and be hands free during your pumping sessions you should consider getting a wearable pump. Some models fit completely inside your bra, making them very discreet so you can pump anytime, anywhere.
  • Purpose: Why are you buying a pump? Not every mom pumps with the same purpose or are at the same stage of their breastfeeding journey: Initiating, building supply or maintaining supply.

If you and your newborn are struggling to get breastfeeding initiated and you want to express for a few days a double breast pump can help.

If you are planning to exclusively breastfeed your baby and only pump occasionally a manual breast pump or single electric breast pump will do the trick.

If you are returning to work but want your baby to keep having breast-milk you will be expressing every day for several months. Consider getting a lightweight portable breast pump and a double electric model, to collect more milk in less time for quick pumping breaks.

If you just want to maintain supply and keep your sessions schedule even when going out or to work, electric wearable pumps are ideal for these situations. They have great suction, fit inside your bra and are very discrete. They will give you the confidence and freedom to pump anytime, anywhere.

  • Milk Supply: Your supply will also influence the type of pump that is best for you. Moms with high supply like to buy a manual pump pump because their pumping sessions are usually short and/or they pump one breast while breastfeeding their baby from the other one. If your supply is not as abundant, a double electric hospital grade breast pump may be ideal for you. Your pumping sessions can take longer and you can benefit from the different suction levels and other features that a double electric pump can offer to help let down, flow, and supply.
  • Ease of use: If you are a first time mom or new at breast pumping this is very important to you. There is a learning curve associated with using breast pumps but some are more challenging than others. Is the pump easy to assemble and to use? To reduce the amount of pisces that need cleaning after each session, consider buying extra bottles/containers and other washable parts.
  • Cost: The cost involved in buying or renting a breast pump can be considerably high for many parents. If you are on a budget, check your insurance policy before buying your breast pump. There are some highly rated pumps that are covered by insurance, even some wearable smart breast pumps accept HSA/FSA funds and/or are eligible for insurance too.

Closed-system Pump vs Open-system Pump?

Although the latest models of breast pumps from reputable brands are leaning toward closed system pumps, you’ll still find open system pumps on the market.

  • Closed-system pumps: It’s the most hygienic style of pumps. This system seals the pump from the milk by using a barrier (backflow protector). This barrier prevents the milk from getting inside the motor and/or in contact with parts that are not sterilized or BPA free. Pumps with a closed-system are usually more expensive but it will protect your milk from harmful bacteria.
  • Open-system pump: These pumps do not have a barrier to prevent the milk from getting inside the pump mechanism. The milk usually flows through all parts and small pieces before arriving in the bottle. Since open system pumps are usually more budget friendly, a solution could be to clean and sterilize every part after each pumping session. It will require extra work and time but it’ll make the process more hygienic.

When Should I Start Using my Breast Pump?

Experts recommend not to start pumping before the 6 weeks after birth but some moms, given the circumstances, may be forced to start earlier. If this is your case, consider using a hospital-grade pump or an electric pump, if possible. At the beginning your breast will only produce a small amount of colostrum, then your supply will slowly increase as you keep pumping and your milk fully comes in.

Consider waiting at least 6 weeks after the birth of your child before you start pumping, if your baby is exclusively breastfeeding and gaining weight as expected. Pumping too soon too much can create an oversupply which could be a problem in the first few months when your baby is demanding less milk. It may keep your breasts engorged for a longer than expected.

If your plan is to exclusively breastfeed your baby for as long as you can and things are going well for you and baby no not rush to start pumping. Breastfeeding your baby is the best trick to help your milk come in and to increase your supply.

Do not be hard on yourself if things aren’t going as planned. Not all moms go through the same journey when it comes to breastfeeding and/or pumping. Consider consulting a lactation expert and/or your family doctor for help.

How Often Should I Clean my Breast Pump?

The FDA recommends that : “All breast pump parts that come in contact with breast milk, such as bottles, valves and breast shields, should be cleaned after each use”…”by thoroughly washing away germs and bacteria with liquid dishwashing soap and warm water.”

This may sound like a lot of work if you are pumping regularly but it is strictly necessary to maintain hygiene and keep the breast milk safe from harmful bacterias. There are some steps you can take in order to minimize the work, like buying extra parts and bottles/containers and buying a pump with dishwasher safe pieces. Buying a closed system pump will reduce the amount of parts that need to be washed after each pumping session.

If your pump tubing comes in contact with the breast milk you will have to wash and hang it to air dry before reattaching it to the breast pump. Be aware that in some pump models, you may see some condensation inside the tubing after you finish pumping. This does not mean you need to wash them, just turn the pump on disconnected from the bottle/container for a few minutes until the tubing is dry.

These are just general guidelines. I recommend checking the pump’s instruction manual for specific information about cleaning your breast pump. It will provide the manufacturer recommended method of cleaning.

FAQ

What is a Breast Pump?

A breast pump is a mechanical device that is used by lactating women to extract breast-milk. There are two main types: manual pumps powered by hand or foot movements and automatic devices powered by electricity (plugged into the wall or battery powered). In the last few years a new style has flooded the market, the hand-free / wearable breast pump. Would you like to know which are the best wearable breast pumps in 2022?

What is the most recommended breast pump brand?

Lansinoh and Medela are the most recommended breast pump brands in North America. Their products are built to the highest standards keeping in mind moms and baby safety first. Their breast pumps are highly rated and usually covered by insurance.

What breast pump is best UK?

The Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 is the best double electric breast pump in the UK. You can find other pumps available through Amazon and other companies’ sites like Medela but they are dated versions or styles. There are other good wearable pumps that might be available in your area.

Which breast pump is best for milk supply?

While many pump manufacturers claim that their pumps are designed to increase your breast milk supply, moms seem to argue about that statement. Medela Pump In Style MaxFlow is a hospital-grade pump that mimics a baby’s natural sucking pattern and some moms recommend it to help you with your supply when having premature babies or not a natural birth. Please keep in mind that there are many factors that can affect your supply and can not be overcome by a breast pump.

How do I know what breast pump to get?

Always get the breast pump that is right for you. Choosing a suitable breast pump depends on many factors: personal lifestyle, milk supply, your baby’s needs, and which stage you’re at on your breastfeeding journey (Initiating, building supply or maintaining supply). Learn more.

Summary

Are you feeling prepared now to choose the right pump for you? I hope our list of best breast pumps narrowed it down and saves you time by not having to research all the brands and read endless lists of reviews.

There are many great options to choose from that fit different lifestyles, milk supply levels and budgets. Remember not to rush when choosing the right flange for your breasts and to be patient if you don’t get it right the first time, all breast pumps have a learning curve, even the best breast pumps.

Do you know which are the nursery ideas dominating this year? The Mini Cribs are high on the list, they have became part of modern and urban nurseries. The volume of moms searching for the best mini cribs and best mini cribs mattresses is on the rise. Don’t miss out!

Similar Posts